Hands-On: Black & Decker’s SC1400 14.4V Li-Ion Drill
By Sean O'HaraSummary/Conclusions
We were more than a little impressed with the big power from this little drill. Black & Decker claims 210 in-lbs of torque, and we suspect that number may be accurate. After drilling 90 holes in oak with the largest bit we could cram in it, we can say this for certain: the SC1400 pushes enough torque to handle any reasonable job around the house. Pretty carbon fiber aside, this isn’t a gimmicky drill.
When comapred to a pro-line drill, it’s missing a few key features: variable speed and a removable battery. But the SC1400 isn’t inteded for pro use, and comparing it to li-ion powered pro drills selling for nearly twice the SC1400’s $100 street price makes little sense.
The SC1400 offers lithium-ion convenience — long runtime, high current delivery, and great charge shelf life — in a consumer level package, lowering the cost by eliminating the key features mentioned above. Considering a 1,000+ cylce lifespan, the integrated battery won’t provde disastrous for most home users. Hardcore users could always re-cell it a few years down the road.
The hardest part for us would be giving up variable speed — especially for metal work. But that sentence indicates that we’re not the SC1400’s target audience, doesn’t it?
And hey — don’t forget that it looks sweet.
SC1400 14.4 Li-Ion Drill [Black & Decker]
Street Pricing [Froogle]
Via Amazon
March 26th, 2007 at 5:12 pm
Well, I’m not quite sure how to say it without sounding offensive - you have a terrific blog, you know a lot and tell us about great tools, but… Well, have you ever read an article or two about various battery chemistries?
There is a BIG problem with LiIon batteries - they die in a few years - basically becoming useless after about two or three years. And, before you ask, it doesn’t matter whether you use them or not, whether you keep them charged or not. They simply die of old age and that cannot be changed.
You can take an old, unfashionable NiCd battery made 30 years ago and used normally from time to time - and it will still run OK. Sure, the energy density is not great (so the battery is heavier than comparable LiIon one), and its self-discharge rate is rather awful (so you have to top it up every couple of months), but it’s still a battery even now.
I don’t have any problems with removable LiIon batteries for professional tools - they are much lighter, more powerful, and when they will die in a couple of years there would be no problem to replace them.
On the other hand an average “consumer” will NOT be happy to throw away the whole tool after using it a couple of times (once a year, to fix something) - and that’s why the abominations like this one are born: to make the abovementioned hobbyist pay every couple of ears for the same tool again and again.
Bosch IXO, this B&D drill and some others come to mind as an example of dishonest marketing - and I’ll be glad if even a single reader will save his or her hard-earned dollars for some other tool to use and to keep as long as needed.
By the way, it would be great if you test the Metabo PowerMaxx LI - I have an older PowerMaxx with NiCd batteries (that will last about ten times as long as sc1400, btw), I really love it, and yet I may want to give it to a friend as a gift and buy myself a PowerMaxx LI if you like it during the review
March 26th, 2007 at 11:10 pm
Not to be a definition nazi, but the “square” bits are Robertsons.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robertson_screwdriver
Very common in Canada - I would guess more popular that Phillips especially if you discount American made products. (I could be quite wrong about that.)
March 27th, 2007 at 1:06 am
I agree, lithium batteries should be removable for exactly the reason you stated. The Skil IXO is so cheap it’s essentially disposable, and the Bosch Litheon removable-pack tools are priced above the hobbyist market. Nobody’s doing it. That’s capitalism at work.
On the other hand, those of us who aren’t afraid to crack the thing open will have an easy time putting new lithium cells into it after picking it up for $5 at a garage sale in 5 years, with only a few hours of use on the motor and transmission.
March 27th, 2007 at 5:24 am
Is it that hard to add variable speed? How much more would it cost?
March 27th, 2007 at 2:17 pm
Dumbest placement for the drill bits… you go to grab the drill handle and stab yourself in the wrist
May 13th, 2007 at 3:39 am
Hi My Name Is ivagbr.
June 20th, 2007 at 9:46 pm
Hello! Good Site! Thanks you! zasxobmmydkg
July 2nd, 2007 at 12:45 pm
Lithium Ion batteries have been powering my laptop (as well as most/all laptops on the market) for 3 years with no problem. Today’s batteries are probably even better.
July 19th, 2007 at 2:54 pm
I bought one of these little drills today. It charged in no time.
Oh! Before I go on.. You said in your review that the SC1400 was not variable speed. Well, I am here to tell you that mine is. Mine was only cost 89 bux so when the L-ion eventually craps out, no big, I’ll just sling it and get another. I had 4 Porter-Cable 12V magna-quench drills all lay down on me in the same day, so I had sworn off buying cordless drills. I rethought my decision when I saw the Lithium-ion drill. The charge time and power to weight ratio got me hook line and sinker. I think I’ll run down and get another soon.
I wish y’all would retract the Variable speed statement.
July 19th, 2007 at 11:54 pm
I think that Greg is right.
http://www.blackanddecker.com/productguide/product-details.aspx?productid=15522&toolview=4#details
It says 0-350 and 0-1400, suggesting that there is variable speed control.
February 29th, 2008 at 5:28 am
I bought one of these at home depot for 89.00. I was very surprized it the perfomance. The chuck is a litlle hoky.
After 6 month it wont hold a charge I am taking the POS back TODAY!
But I am gonna try another , cus I like the form factor.
July 18th, 2008 at 12:10 pm
I am currently experiencing the battery issue. I just found out that my PS180 B&D charger was blown because one of the three batteries I was charging was bad. I just purchased a new charger on line for $33.00 including shipping because the stores no longer carry them. How can I tell which battery is bad so I don’t blow the charger too? Thankfully I had an old corded drill to fall back on…! The battery powered is more convenient.
August 17th, 2008 at 10:36 am
I need the charging station for a Black and Decker SC1400. Any ideas?
Jack
October 2nd, 2008 at 12:07 pm
I too purchased the SC1400 a while ago. Tons of power and torque that last a long time, but…
Gripes: The trigger (which is variable speed) doesn’t allow you to run slow enough RPM’s to carefully start screws. The variable torque setting has a huge difference between setting 3 and 4. 3 is not enough torque, and 4 is basically full-on drill setting.
All in all the drill has terrific power, very light weight and comfortable. B & D should have made the variable speed run slow enough (0 - XXX RPM), and a more refined torque clutch.